Pittsburgh Pirates pitcher Trevor Williams had a tough decision to make Thursday night. After a waiter mistook Williams for Bryce Harper, Williams could either admit he was a different baseball player, or go along with the lie. Williams chose the latter.

Because of that, there’s a waiter out there who thinks Bryce Harper is definitely signing with the New York Yankees.

Yikes. Hopefully that waiter didn’t go home and tell all his friends he just got the baseball scoop of a lifetime.

In Williams’ defense, Harper could technically sign with the Yankees. The team hasn’t been linked to Harper much this offseason, but you can’t count the Yankees out when it comes to premier free agents.