July 21
Newsday
columnist Wallace Matthews
"
Taken at face value, this should be a heartwarming story, a tale of twin redemptions for Andy Pettitte and Jason Giambi. One suffered through an offseason of embarrassment, the other muddled through an April of abasement. Both came through in a big way in yesterday's 2-1 victory over the Oakland Athletics at Yankee Stadium...It was a win to remember, to be sure. But was it a win to be proud of? Was it real? Was it clean?
Those are the questions you'd rather not have to wrestle with, but considering the players involved and their well-publicized history, they refuse to go away."