More like do nothing, am I right, Yankees fans?
The Yankees did not approach this 2017 season with an all-in mentality. They have not earned the right during the season to be all-in. So they should maintain the path they have created for themselves and not break up their loaded farm system to keep their declining hopes alive.
It’s the right decision. It also might prove to be the popular decision.
This is not the time to make a big deal for a starting pitcher. Let the Dodgers, Royals, Red Sox and Astros capture the trade-deadline headlines, just as other teams largely dominated last winter’s Hot Stove League. While Sonny Gray and Jose Quintana count as good pitchers who can be controlled beyond 2017, they need not cause you to tear up your map and start fresh.
In their last 22 games, the Yankees have gone 6-16. That they started the year 38-23 before experiencing this massive market correction evokes the quality plummet in “The Flash” from Season 1 to Season 2. They’re good enough that they probably won’t crash all the way below .500; many of their losses during this slump can be attributed to a leaky bullpen that should fix itself, and Starlin Castro, Matt Holliday and Aaron Hicks should return from the disabled list, in that order, and improve the lineup. Yet they don’t appear good enough to turn right back around and play the sort of high-level ball that put them atop the American League East for the better part of a month and a half.
So they should keep going as is; if they can rent a first baseman like Oakland’s Yonder Alonso and the Mets’ Lucas Duda, who will cost minimal talent and a few bucks, then they should do that. None of their top guys should be sacrificed, though, for what looks increasingly like a long-shot bid for October relevance.
Remember, a year ago at this time, the Yankees (in far worse shape at the time) held fierce internal debates about what to do. Hal Steinbrenner was admittedly hesitant to draw the white flag by trading Carlos Beltran, Aroldis Chapman, Andrew Miller and Ivan Nova. Brian Cashman won over the Yankees’ managing general partner, however, and Steinbrenner, a student of social media, quickly appreciated how positively the Yankees’ fan base reacted to his organization’s long-term thinking.