James Reimer and Jonas Gustavsson sat side-by-side in their stalls at the MasterCard Centre when a reporter asked which one was starting Saturday night against the Ottawa Senators.

They both laughed.

"We both are," said Reimer. "We're going with four skaters and two goalies."

Truth is, Reimer is getting his second start in a row. He just shut out the Pittsburgh Penguins on Wednesday — just his second start of 2012 — and Leaf coach Ron Wilson figures the goalie deserved the chance.

"It's who we feel most comfortable with, and who's playing well," said Leafs coach Ron Wilson. "Reimer deserves to back up that shutout he had the other night by getting another start."