"Granted, Donovan McNabb isn't exactly 2009 Brett Favre when it comes to resurrecting his career in Year 1 with the Vikings.

But is he as good after three games as the 2010 version of Favre he replaced?

Or as good as the quarterback the Vikings threw away before this season, Tarvaris Jackson?

Or even as good as the 2010 version of McNabb that was essentially run out of Washington?

The answers: No, no and no. "